Sunday 19th May 2024,
North Yorks Enquirer

BREAKING: Police & Crime Panel Member In Pub Brawl

BREAKING: Police & Crime Panel Member In Pub Brawl

  • an “In My View” article by NIGEL WARD, covering emerging unofficial reports from within SBC and NYCC.


Unofficial sources within Scarborough Borough Council and North Yorkshire County Council are reporting news of a violent assault on a member of the public allegedly committed by a Conservative member of the Police & Crime Panel for North Yorkshire, in a Hunmanby public house.

Having requested clarity, via Twitter, from:

  • Julia MULLIGAN Police and Crime Commissioner for North Yorkshire;
  • North Yorkshire County Council;
  • Scarborough Borough Council;
  • SBC Press Officer Gabrielle JANDZIO;
  • SBC Portfolio Holder for Democracy, Neighbourhoods and Stronger & Safer Communities Councillor Michelle DONAHUE-MONCRIEFF, and
  • Yorkshire Coast Radio

I have, at the time of writing, nothing further to report on the incident. Lips are sealed.

It is disappointing – though hardly unexpected – that the recipients of my Tweets have found themselves unable promptly to provide a transparent response.

Obviously, the mere suspicion that a member of the Police & Crime Panel (the body that supervises Police & Crime Commissioner Julia MULLIGAN’s much-criticised supervision of the North Yorkshire Police) – or, for that matter, of Scarborough Borough Council or North Yorkshire County Council – has been involved in a physical assault on a member of the public could reasonably be expected to result in a timely resignation, irrespective of whether or not charges have been made.


Meanwhile, in other news, congratulations are in order to SBC Councillor Sandra TURNER [Con.], who has today been appointed Portfolio Holder for Democracy, Neighbourhoods and Stronger & Safer Communities, replacing SBC Councillor Michelle DONOHUE-MONCRIEFF [Con.].

In a statement to Councillors late this afternoon (Thurs 8th September 2016), SBC Director of Legal & Democtraic Services Lisa DIXON, on behalf of SBC Leader Councillor Derek BASTIMAN [Con.] stated:

“The Leader has asked me to inform you that there is a new Portfolioholder for Democracy, Neighbourhoods, Safer & Stronger Communities. The Leader is pleased to welcome Whitby Councillor Sandra Turner to Cabinet and wishes her well in her new role.

In the meantime, the Leader would like to take this opportunity to thank Councillor Michelle Donohue Moncrieff for her contribution towards the Council’s work.”

It is indeed an ill wind that blows nobody any good.

Opposition Councillors are assuming that the Leader has, for the moment at least, succeeded in persuading the out-going Portfolio Holder not to resign from the Council itself – though calls for a resignation are generally anticipated. It would appear to be one of those occasions when a strenuous round of “After you!”-“No, after you!” ensues.

Good luck, Sandra – and stay clean.


Comments are closed.