Thursday 18th July 2024,
North Yorks Enquirer

Another One Bites The Dust

June 7, 2020 Misc, Police

Another One Bites The Dust



Rosie Duffield MP resigns as Parliamentary Whip

In the latest scandal over breaches of the lockdown rules by prominent public figures, Labour MP Rosie Duffield has resigned as the opposition whip having admitted breaching the Lockdown Regulations.

Ms Duffield met her boyfriend at her Canterbury constituency, and they went for a five-hour walk together. Her boyfriend is married and still living with his wife, so this is a breach of the Coronavirus Lockdown Regulations ban on persons from different households meeting.

Ms Duffield states that she observed the social distancing regulations, but nevertheless accepted that this was a breach of the lockdown rules.

I cannot help but say that I admire Ms Duffield for her honesty. She admitted the offence, apologised and stood down. You cannot have a member of the legislature breaking the law at a time of national crisis. Particularly as she is a Parliamentary Whip responsible for enforcing discipline on her party’s MPs. So I think she has done the right thing. BBC report here.

Ms Duffield compared to other public figures that breached the lockdown rules:

Compare her conduct to recent examples of public figures that have been caught out blatantly breaching the lockdown rules:

  • Mr Dominic Cummings. Advisor to the Prime Minister, who took his family on a 260 mile drive to stay with his parents in a cottage on their farm in Durham. He then took them on a drive to a beauty spot because he says he believed his eyesight, may not be good enough for driving.
  • Professor Neil Ferguson. Prominent advisor to the government on its response to the COVID 19 crisis, who had a meeting with is married girlfriend, thereby risking infecting himself, his girlfriend, her husband and her family.
  • Dr Catherine Calderwood. Chief Medical Officer for Scotland, who received a police caution for taking her family on two trips to her holiday home.

Chief Constable Lisa Winward and Mr Dominic Cummings

  • Chief Constable Lisa Winward. Chief Constable of North Yorkshire Police, who undertook multiple unnecessary visits to police stations.
  • Deputy Chief Constable Phil Cain, who undertook a totally unnecessary visit to Scarborough police station and attended a retirement ceremony there where he did not observe social distancing. Deputy Chief Constable Cain then publicly castigated members of the public, for breaching the regulations in the same way that he had done.

The Chief Constable Winward and Deputy Chief Constable Cain story was broken exclusively by the NYE.

Deputy Chief Constable Phil Cain ignoring social distancing rules, while undertaking an unnecessary visit to Scarborough Police Station and calling members of the public idiots for doing the same

Disgustingly, only Professor Ferguson had the decency to admit his mistake and resign straight away – the honourable and responsible course of action under the circumstances.

For the rest, Dr Calderwood admitted that she had breached the regulations and tried to bluff it out, before resigning. Mr Cummings tried to explain his way out of it and appears to have succeeded, thanks to the acquiesence of the Prime Minister. Chief Constable Winward and Deputy Chief Constable Cain appear to be trying to bluff their way out of accepting any consequences for their actions, by refusing to comment at all.

Ms Duffield’s actions may have risked infecting herself, her boyfriend and his wife. However, other more prominent public figures have committed far worse breaches of the lockdown regulations. Her transgression was certainly much less serious than those indulged in by the North Yorkshire’s Chief Constable and Deputy Chief Constable, but she has nevertheless done the honourable thing and set the appropriate example.

Dominic Cummings: The plot thickens

There have been major developments in the Dominic Cummings scandal. It has now been alleged that:

  • Mr Cummings jointly owns the property in Durham, making it a second home and therefore making his journey a clear breach of the Coronavirus Regulations.
  • The cottage Mr Cummings stayed in in his father’s estate in Durham is separate from the main farm building, but is apparently not registered for Council Tax.
  • The Cottage does not have planning permission. Source: here. According to this BBC Report the local Council have started an investigation into possible breaches of planning law by Mr Cummings.

The Cummings Effect

The police in North Wales have noted an increase in people breaking the lockdown rules and attributed this to the media coverage generated by Mr Cummings actions. Quoted in this BBC article, Mr Arfon Jones (Police, Fire & Crime Commissioner for North Wales) asserted that Mr Cummings actions meant that people were ignoring the Lockdown Regulations because they thought “they can do whatever they like“.

North Wales has been particularly badly affected and has the highest number of coronavirus cases in Wales. North Wales Police have noticed an increase in people travelling to Wales for day trips. However, I think it is unfair to blame this entirely on Mr Cummings. He is not the only prominent person who has publicly undermined the government’s efforts to protect the NHS and save lives by breaching the rules.

All the “idiots” like Mr Cummings, Dr Calderwood, Professor Ferguson, Ms Duffield, Deputy Chief Constable Cain and Chief Constable Winward who have flagrantly disobeyed the Lockdown rules have responsibility for this – not just Mr Cummings.

The NYE will continue to follow this story.

The Lockdown Rules

The NYE has been doing everything it can to support the efforts of the vast majority of NYP officers to protect the public, by promulgating police information on the lockdown rules.

Chief Constable Winward can be heard in this Yorkshire Cost Radio article here explaining the lockdown rules and giving police advice not to travel. (The same advice that she and Deputy Chief Constable Cain ignored).

North Yorkshire Police released the figures for fines for breaching the Coronavirus regulations in North Yorkshire. Statement here.

The Winward effect

This photograph of three out-of-force-area Cleveland Police motorbikes parked up on the Fish Pier in Whitby has arrived on my desk. I understand that the Officers they belong to did not observe social distancing. This is evidenced from the proximity of the bikes to each other.

They were all three seen having a wonderful time sitting on the same bench in the sun, feasting on fish and chips from one of Whitby’s finest purveyors of the same, in full view of the public.

I am informed they also accepted an invitation from a lady to have a look round a holiday cottage, again not observing social distancing.

It is unclear what official duties they were on, what called them to Whitby and why they were on patrol (that is “Fish and Chip Patrol”) in another force area.

Obviously it is deeply regrettable that Police Officers should publicly undermine the social distancing rules, given that North Yorkshire Police are arresting members of the public and fining them for committing similar offences. However, this is what you have to expect when the Chief Constable and Deputy Chief Constable themselves undermine force discipline by breaching the Lockdown rules.

A request has been made to NYP for a media statement, which was not available at the time of publication.

In this context, to deter people from breaching the lockdown rules and in accordance with our policy of “Name & Shame”, if you become aware of a public figure or Police Officer breaching the Lockdown rules, please photograph/video them using your mobile ‘phone and inform the NYE using the email address.

Right of Reply

If you are mentioned in this article and do not agree with the views expressed in it, or if you wish to correct any factual inaccuracy, please let me know and your views and a correction will be published if appropriate.

Comments are closed.